Know how the CCPs you depend on would hold up under stress

Our independent risk assessments show how each central counterparty manages the risk it concentrates, where your exposure sits and what could happen to your collateral and positions if things go wrong.

29

CCPs assessed

Daily

Newsflashes

Intraday

monitoring

9

risk categories assessed

Some of the most systemically important institutions in finance

Central counterparties (CCPs) sit at the centre of global derivatives and equities markets. By standing between buyers and sellers, they reduce bilateral counterparty risk, but they also concentrate it. Our assessments show how that concentrated risk is managed and what controls are in place so you understand your exposure and how it could change under stress.

Since post-2008 reforms made central clearing mandatory for many OTC derivatives, CCPs have become some of the most systemically important institutions in the financial system. They clear OTC derivatives, listed derivatives and domestic cash markets, and a growing share of market activity passes through a small number of them. No two CCPs work in the same way. Each has its own:

Square Tick

Margin models

How initial and variation margin are calculated, and how they respond to volatility

Square Tick

Default waterfall

The order in which resources are used when a member fails

Square Tick

Financial resources

The size of the default fund and the CCP's own capital at risk ("skin in the game")

Square Tick

Ownership and governance

Whose interests drive risk decisions 

These differences matter. A CCP failure, or even serious stress at one, can cause losses, liquidity strain and disruption for clearing members, their clients and the wider market.

What would happen to you if a CCP came under stress?

Before you choose a CCP, or decide whether to keep using one, you need clear answers to some critical questions:

    • What happens to your collateral if a member defaults? Is it segregated, and how well is it protected?
    • What happens to your open positions? Could they be auctioned, transferred or torn up?
    • How quickly is your default fund contribution at risk? If a major participant fails, how many layers of protection sit in front of your capital?
    • Can you be asked for more? Which assessment rights, loss allocation or recovery tools could the CCP use?
    • How resilient is the CCP itself? Could an operational failure, cyber-attack or liquidity shortfall disrupt clearing when you need it most?

These answers are rarely in one place, and they're hard to compare across CCPs. Our assessments do that work for you.

ccp-risk-assessments-50-50-image-block-offered-hand

Independent assessment of CCPs as concentrators of risk

We help firms meet regulatory and risk requirements to assess and monitor the CCPs they use.

Each assessment shows how well a CCP protects you from risk, and how much of that risk could ultimately fall back on you. You get:

Forensics

Transparency

A clear, independent view of how each CCP operates, how it would respond to stress and where your exposure lies.
Documents

Comparability

One methodology applied to every CCP, so you can benchmark them against each other.

Efficiency

Efficiency and cost savings

Use our research in place of building and maintaining your own CCP due diligence.

Monitoring

Ongoing monitoring

Updates when material changes happen, so your view of risk stays current between reviews.

We assess CCP risk across six categories

Person

Counterparty risk

How robust the CCP's membership criteria, margin methodology and default management process are, and how well its default waterfall protects members who haven't defaulted.

Efficiency x3

Liquidity risk

Whether the CCP can meet its payment obligations on time under stress, including the quality and accessibility of its liquid resources.

Secure

Asset safety

How client and member collateral is held, segregated and protected, including custody arrangements, investment policy and portability.

Graph

Financial risk

The strength of the CCP's balance sheet, its capital adequacy, its skin in the game and how sustainable its business model is.

Network

Operational risk

How resilient the CCP's systems, processes and third-party dependencies are, including cybersecurity, business continuity and recovery capability.

Monitoring Expertise

Governance and transparency

How the CCP is owned and governed, how risk decisions are made and challenged, and how clearly it discloses information to participants.

Supporting everyone with exposure to CCPs

    • Clearing members and banks managing exposure to the CCPs where they clear
    • Asset managers and buy-side firms assessing risk to client collateral and positions
    • Risk, compliance and due diligence teams meeting regulatory requirements
    • Regulators and market infrastructure bodies monitoring systemic concentration
ccp-risk-assessments-50-50-image-block-team-handshake

Aligned with international standards

Our methodology follows internationally recognised standards, including the CPMI-IOSCO Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures (PFMI). It helps you show regulators and internal stakeholders that your CCP exposures are being identified, assessed and monitored.

ccp-risk-assessments-50-50-image-block-st-pauls-dome

Deep expertise in market infrastructure risk

Square Tick

Independent

Objective analysis, free from CCP or member influence 

Square Tick

Consistent

One methodology across every CCP, built on best practices

Square Tick

Specialist

Decades of experience in FMI and post-trade risk, alongside our monitoring of more than 140 CSDs (link to the CSD Risk Assessments page)

Square Tick

Current

Updates when material changes occur

Understand your CCP exposure

Find out how the CCPs you rely on would perform under stress, and what that would mean for you.

Jim Micklethwaite | Managing Director, Head of FMIs

Jim Micklethwaite

Managing Director | Head of FMIs

jmicklethwaite@thomasmurray.com

Panagiotis Kiziris | Director, FMIs

Panagiotis Kiziris

Get in touch

Send us a few details and a member of our team will be in touch shortly.

Frequently asked questions

CCPs reduce bilateral counterparty risk but concentrate it in a few institutions. Firms that clear through or rely on CCPs need to understand how that risk is managed and what it could mean for their collateral, positions and default fund contributions.